Skip to Content

Failed Colony of Roanoke

Failed Colony of Roanoke

Sharing is caring!

The Roanoke Colony, often referred to as the Lost Colony, remains one of the most enduring mysteries in American history. Established in 1587 by English settlers, the colony was an ambitious endeavor by Sir Walter Raleigh to establish a permanent settlement in the New World. Located on Roanoke Island in what is now North Carolina, the colony was intended to serve as a foothold for England in North America, but its fate was sealed by a series of unforeseen events.

When John White, appointed as the governor of the colony, returned in 1590 from a supply trip to England, he found Roanoke deserted with no clear indication of what had become of the settlers. The only clues left behind were the word “Croatoan” carved into a post and “CRO” etched into a tree, suggesting a possible relocation to Croatoan Island, now known as Hatteras Island. Despite various theories, the disappearance of the settlers has never been conclusively explained, leading to speculation and investigation for centuries.

Theories about the Lost Colony range from assimilation with local Native American tribes to victimization at the hands of hostile groups or abandonment following the scarcity of resources. The lack of definitive evidence has made the Lost Colony a topic of research, debate, and cultural fascination, underscoring the challenges faced by early colonizers and the complexities of colonial interactions with indigenous populations. Despite numerous archaeological digs and scholarly studies, the ultimate fate of the Roanoke settlers is a piece of history that remains unsolved.

Historical Context

The Roanoke Colony, established in the late 16th century, was an ambitious endeavor marked by its abrupt and mysterious disappearance. Historical context is essential to understanding the events that led to its founding and eventual fate.

Queen Elizabeth I’s Charter

In 1584, Queen Elizabeth I granted Sir Walter Raleigh a charter to explore, colonize, and govern lands in the New World.

This charter was instrumental in the founding of the Roanoke Colony, as it gave Raleigh the authority to establish a permanent English settlement in North America, with the goals of expanding the British Empire and profiting from potential resources.

England’s Motivations

England was motivated by economic interests, national prestige, and religious competition with Spain. The English sought to establish colonies to:

  • Extract resources to enrich the crown and private investors
  • Create a base for privateering against the Spanish treasure fleet
  • Spread Protestantism as a counter to Catholic Spain

The Roanoke expedition was an early attempt to assert English power and influence across the Atlantic, contributing to the larger context of European exploration and colonization during this period.

First Attempts

The English initially explored the area of Roanoke Island in 1584 under the direction of Sir Walter Raleigh.

Two expeditions, one in 1584 and another in 1585, were sent to scout the location and establish relations with native populations. However, these early endeavors faced difficulties such as scarce resources, leading to their abandonment.

A more deliberate effort was undertaken in 1587 when artist and explorer John White led a group of 115 settlers to establish a colony on Roanoke Island.

The group included men, women, and children, indicating intentions of a permanent settlement. White was appointed Governor and tasked with the colony’s establishment and sustenance.

John White returned to England for supplies shortly after establishing the colony, leaving behind the settlers, including his granddaughter Virginia Dare, the first English child born in the Americas.

Due to the war with Spain, White’s return to Roanoke was delayed. When he finally arrived in 1590, the colony was deserted with no trace of the inhabitants except for the word “Croatoan” carved into a post, leading to the enduring mystery of the “Lost Colony.”

The Disappearance

Numerous theories have surfaced regarding the fate of the Roanoke settlers. Some suggest that they assimilated with local Native American tribes, possibly seeking their assistance to survive.

Others propose that they met with a tragic end due to starvation, disease, or conflict with indigenous peoples.

John White, the colony’s governor, returned in 1590 after a delayed resupply mission from England to find Roanoke abandoned. The only clue was the word “Croatoan” carved into a post, indicating a possible move to Croatoan Island, known today as Hatteras Island. However, severe weather prevented him from investigating further.

Search for Evidence

Scholars have been studying maps and historical records to piece together what happened to the colonists. One example is the Virginea Pars map, drawn by Governor John White, which has provided clues through hidden markings that were revealed under modern analysis.

Documents from the period, including accounts from returning colonists and notes by Thomas Harriot, have been scrutinized for any indication of the settlers’ fate or their intended destination upon leaving Roanoke Island.

In recent excavations, archaeologists have discovered artifacts that suggest a coexistence between the English settlers and the indigenous populations.

For instance, European pottery shards were located in areas that were historically inhabited by Native Americans, indicating a possible assimilation of colonists into native communities. These findings are part of the ongoing efforts at sites like “Site X,” which might have been a relocation point for the Roanoke settlers.

Historical Significance

The disappearance of the Roanoke settlers marks a profound mystery in early American history. It represents the failed attempt to establish the first permanent English settlement in North America, a pivotal moment before the eventual establishment of Jamestown.

Its enduring legacy continues to intrigue historians and laypersons alike, forming a significant aspect of the narrative of American colonization.

In literature and media, the story of the Lost Colony has been a subject of fascination. Numerous books, plays, and films have been inspired by the mystery, often adding speculative or fictional interpretations to the historical facts.

For example, the word “Croatoan” found carved into a tree at the deserted colony site has been referenced in various works, symbolizing the enduring enigma.

Contemporary Investigations

Current genetic research efforts aim to trace potential lineage connections between the lost colonists and modern populations.

These projects collect and analyze DNA samples from individuals with historical ties to the area or to the Roanoke settlers.

By comparing ancient and contemporary genetic markers, researchers hope to find evidence of the colonists’ survival and integration with local Native American tribes.

Sharing is caring!

Eric Pearson

Thursday 18th of January 2024

Probably a hurricane came about and they moved to another place possibly on the coastline and just live out their lives with the natives

Marion McHenry

Thursday 18th of January 2024

This is Very Interesting to Me a Many Times GreatGrandmother of mine was a Native American and lived on Maryland's Eastern Shore!

Patricia Ann Sportsman

Wednesday 17th of January 2024

I don't understand why there can't be DNA testing done between the relatives of John White and the blue-eyed potential descendants of the people of Hatteras? So it has been over 500 years? I have ancestors in my DNA from just as long if not longer ago than that. Certainly someone like John White, appointed governor of the colony, must have some descendants? Archaeological pursuits have done part of the research. We should extend every possibility to find out what happened to The Lost Colony of Roanoke.